Why AI ‘can’t replace journalists in communities’

Nov 20, 2026 at 03:20 pm


Local and independent news publishers in Australia have stepped up their use of AI by a half, a survey has found.

The findings come from a LINA survey of 85 of its members, which noted that they were “just as likely to be led by women as men”.

Almost three quarters (73 per cent) of respondents reported using AI in their organisation, up from 51 per cent in 2025, with research moving to the top use for AI users (86 per cent) followed closely by administrative or operational tasks (82 per cent) and “limited” editorial support. Of respondents who used AI, 40 per cent applied it to image generation, and 16 per cent used it for content generation.

A survey members that had completed the survey every year since LINA’s founding in 2023 showed median annual revenue had grown only $20,000 since 2025, to $189,000 2026, while FTE staff numbers had grown from 1.3 to 2.0.

Executive director Claire Stuchbery (pictured) described the LINA findings as “broadly encouraging”, despite continuing challenges and the impacts of rising costs, a soft advertising market and rapid developments in AI.

“But publishers are resilient,” she said. “Reassuringly, it seems many are saving time by using AI for operational and administrative tasks, but use for editorial purposes remains minimal.

“AI cannot, and should not, replace the work of journalists spending time in communities, speaking with and interviewing people, analysing information with important cultural and locally relevant context, and fact-checking and verification.”

She said government support through the Journalism Assistance Fund had provided welcome help for publishers during this period, with grants rising as a revenue source but advertising remaining in the top spot.

Most of the news organisations surveyed had been founded within the past decade, many in response to the closing or contracting of legacy newspapers causing news deserts in local areas. Respondents shared stories about their most impactful reporting from the year, including sending minute-by-minute notifications of emergency updates during bushfires, breaking news of environmental harm, sharing otherwise untold local stories, and exposing wrongdoing prompting council, government or ministerial response.

Just over half (54 per cent) of respondents rated the future of their news organisation as secure, with a third saying their future was uncertain or at risk, prompting Stuchbery to reprise her call for ongoing support to enable the sector continue providing an important public service. “It’s absolutely critical that journalists and publishers are compensated for use of their work, including by AI models,” she said.

“I hope funders and philanthropists can also come to the table and recognise news services as essential community infrastructure that underpins community development, local leadership and regional identity for all Australian communities.

“We need news to navigate our day to day lives, stay connected to one another, and for a functioning democracy.”

Sections: Newsmedia industry

Comments

or Register to post a comment




ADVERTISEMENTS


ADVERTISEMENTS